Pusateri's Chicago Pizza

Peter Conti 2 months ago

Very disappointing first experience. I'd heard the pizza was excellent and had been wanting to try Pusateri's for quite a while. Their posted hours say they're open until 8:00 p.m., so we arrived at about 7:25 p.m. expecting to have dinner. Instead, we were told they were no longer accepting dine-in customers and that only takeout orders were being accepted. If dine-in service ends before your posted closing time, that should be clearly stated. Otherwise, customers naturally assume they can still be seated before closing. My wife and I dine out five or six nights a week and were hoping to add Pusateri's to our regular rotation. Instead, we left without eating and won't be returning. A restaurant's advertised hours should accurately reflect when customers can still receive the service they're expecting.

George Black 5 months ago

The restaurant is gorgeous and is a really fun place to get a bite. The service was great, although there did seem to a bit of a delay ordering online. I ordered the John Hancock, so my review is for that pizza only. The pizza was, unfortunately, my least favorite part of the experience. It was cooked perfect and all the toppings were good, it just seemed to be lacking flavor somehow, and I think it might have been the sauce. Some positive feedback is that the pizza felt really fresh and clean. Grated, it could just come down to my pallet. Great place overall and I recommend everyone check it out and support an awesome local restaurant!

Tracey Khan 5 months ago

Boasting delicious Chicago Thin Crust Pizza. It delivered.. Downtown adjacent in Stuart. Definitely was worth the trip to try it out.

Trent Wetherald 5 months ago

If you are looking for authentic Windy City flavors, Pusateri's Chicago Pizza is the real deal. Finding a spot that nails both the classic comfort foods and specialized dietary needs is rare, but this place knocks it out of the park. ​The Highlights ​The Chicago Dog: This is a masterclass in tradition. It was dragged through the garden exactly the way it should be—poppy seed bun, bright green relish, sport peppers, and that perfect snap to the frank. It tasted like it came straight from a stand in the Loop. ​Gluten-Free Crust Pizza: It is often hard to find a gluten-free crust that actually holds up to the weight of Chicago-style toppings, but Pusateri’s has perfected it. The crust was crisp, flavorful, and didn't feel like a compromise at all. It’s clear they take care with their ingredients and preparation. ​The Atmosphere: The vibe is welcoming and down-to-earth, making it a great spot for a casual meal where the food is the star of the show. ​Final Verdict ​Pusateri's delivers big on flavor and authenticity. Whether you're craving a nostalgic hot dog or need a safe, delicious gluten-free pizza option, this is easily one of the best spots in the area. We’ll definitely be reg

Leigh 9 months ago

I am staying around the corner at Molly's house, and Pusateri's has been a delicious blessing during our stay. Thank you for what you do for us, and also that cheese garlic bread, pepperoni pizza with hot hiney, and peanut butter pie is PHENOMENAL. Thank you for the amazing hospitality and experience. Your staff is also 10/10!